Every writing tool promises to make you sound smarter. Grammarly is the only one I have kept installed for nine years, and that is partly stubbornness and partly because it keeps catching the thing I cannot see: my own typo, three hours into a draft, in the sentence I have already read four times.
For this review I did not run benchmark sentences. I used it the way you would — on invoices, on cold emails, on a 40,000-word document written across two months, and on the messy Slack messages I send before coffee.
What Grammarly actually catches
The core engine is very good at the boring stuff and quietly excellent at one specific thing: missing words. When you rewrite a sentence halfway through, you leave debris behind. Grammarly finds that debris almost every time. Over three months it flagged 412 issues in my work. I accepted 268. Of the ones I rejected, most were style opinions rather than errors.
- Real errors caught: dropped words, subject-verb mismatch, wrong preposition, inconsistent tense
- Frequently wrong: dialogue, deliberate fragments, technical jargon, brand names
- Genuinely useful: the tone indicator, which told me an email read as 'disapproving' before I sent it to a client
Where it makes your writing worse
Accept every suggestion and you will end up with prose that sounds like a HR memo. Grammarly hates short sentences, distrusts semicolons and wants to replace any interesting verb with a safer one. Writers with a voice should treat the style panel as advice from a cautious colleague, not an editor.
The AI rewrite feature has the same problem in a bigger package. It produces competent, sanded-down paragraphs. Fine for a status update. Not fine for anything anyone chooses to read.
Pricing: the honest maths
Pro costs $12 a month on the annual plan, or $30 if you pay monthly — one of the widest gaps in the category, and a nudge you should notice. Free covers spelling, grammar and basic clarity. Pro adds full-sentence rewrites, tone rewriting, plagiarism detection and a much bigger AI allowance.
My rule after three months: if writing is how you earn money, buy it. If you write a handful of emails a day, the free plan is already more than most people use.
Alternatives worth a look
ProWritingAid gives deeper reports and a one-off lifetime licence, which suits novelists. Microsoft Editor is included with Microsoft 365 and is good enough for internal documents. If you mainly want AI drafting rather than correction, a general assistant such as Claude will do more for the same money.
Verdict
Grammarly is not magic and it will not make you a better writer. It makes you a less embarrassing one, everywhere you type, with almost no friction — and after three months that turned out to be worth the subscription for me and probably not for my brother, who writes four emails a week.